Disney World’s lowest-rated hotel on TripAdvisor, and why it’s not as bad as it sounds
Curious which Walt Disney World resort sits at the bottom of TripAdvisor’s guest rankings? We looked it up. The “worst” Disney-owned hotel might surprise you, and the reasons behind its rating are more “budget trade-offs” than “avoid at all costs.” Here’s the honest breakdown.
Ever wondered which Walt Disney World hotel guests rate the lowest? We headed to TripAdvisor to find out, and the answer comes with a big, important asterisk.
The lowest-rated Disney-owned resort isn’t a disaster, in fact, it scores pretty well. But it does land at the bottom of the pack for some specific, understandable reasons. Here’s which hotel it is, why it ranks where it does, and whether it’s actually right for your trip.
The “worst” Disney-owned hotel on TripAdvisor
Let’s get right to the answer.
According to TripAdvisor guest rankings, Disney’s All-Star Sports Resort consistently comes in as the lowest-rated of Disney’s own Walt Disney World hotels.
But here’s the asterisk, and it matters a lot: “lowest-rated” doesn’t mean “bad.” All-Star Sports still holds a solid 3.9 out of 5 on TripAdvisor, with thousands of reviews, and ranks a respectable #150 out of nearly 400 Orlando-area hotels.
So this isn’t a roach-motel situation, it’s the bottom of a very high-quality barrel. It’s simply the Disney resort guests rate lowest relative to the others.
Why does it rank at the bottom?
Here’s what the reviews actually say, and most of it comes down to it being a budget hotel.
All-Star Sports is one of Disney’s Value Resorts, the most affordable (and most basic) tier on property. The common complaints, pulled from real guest reviews, are pretty consistent:
Basic, less-immersive theming. Of Disney’s three All-Star resorts (Sports, Music, and Movies), reviewers often find Sports the least charming and immersive.
Small, motel-style rooms. The rooms are compact, with exterior hallways that open to the outdoors, more roadside-motel than magical.
Noise and rowdiness. This is a big one. Because it sits near Disney’s ESPN Wide World of Sports complex, All-Star Sports frequently hosts youth sports teams and travel groups. That can mean noise, crowds, and a less relaxing vibe.
Bus congestion. The All-Star resorts sometimes share bus transportation, and when big groups are staying, waits for park buses can get long.
None of these are scandals, they’re the predictable trade-offs of booking Disney’s cheapest option.
The flip side: it has real strengths
Here’s the other half of the story, because a low ranking doesn’t tell you everything.
Plenty of guests genuinely love All-Star Sports, and the reviews reflect that too:
It’s the cheapest way to stay on Disney property. For a lot of families, that’s the whole point, you get all the on-site perks (early park entry, Disney transportation) at the lowest price.
The rooms are clean and updated. Disney has been renovating the All-Star rooms, and recent guests frequently praise how clean and refreshed they are.
Friendly service and fun theming for kids. The larger-than-life sports décor (giant footballs, basketballs) is a hit with sports-loving kids, and guests regularly call out helpful cast members.
For travelers who plan to be in the parks from open to close and just need a clean, affordable place to sleep, All-Star Sports does exactly what it’s supposed to.
One important caveat: it depends who you ask
Here’s a wrinkle worth knowing before you take any single ranking as gospel.
“Worst Disney hotel” changes depending on which site and method you use. TripAdvisor guest scores point to All-Star Sports. But other outlets land elsewhere, some ranking systems that weigh value for money actually knock pricier hotels for being overpriced, and a few reviews on other platforms have pointed at moderate resorts like Coronado Springs (often dinged for its convention-center vibe and sprawling layout).
In other words, there’s no single undisputed “worst.” It all depends on whether you care most about price, theming, location, or luxury.
The bottom line
If you’re going purely by TripAdvisor guest ratings, Disney’s All-Star Sports Resort is the lowest-rated Disney-owned hotel at Walt Disney World, but its 3.9-star score tells the real story: it’s a perfectly fine budget hotel, not a place to avoid.
The “worst” label really just means it’s the most basic. If you want immersive theming, quiet, and space, you’ll be happier paying up for a Moderate or Deluxe resort. But if your priority is staying on Disney property for the lowest possible price, and you don’t mind small rooms and a lively, sporty crowd, All-Star Sports delivers exactly what it promises.
Sometimes the “worst” hotel is just the one that’s honest about being basic, and priced accordingly. Know what you’re booking, and it might be the perfect fit.
Article compiled with the help of the Pirates & Princesses newsroom.
Pirates and Princesses is your destination for Disney news, theme park updates, and the pop culture you love. From Disney cruises and travel tips to Disney fashion, food, collectibles, and movie news, PNP covers it all. Visit us at piratesandprincesses.net for daily coverage. Follow PNP on Facebook and Instagram, and listen to the Pirates & Princesses podcast on Apple Podcasts and YouTube.
Hat Tips:
TripAdvisor (2026), verified for Disney’s All-Star Sports Resort’s rating (3.9 of 5, ranked #150 of 395 Orlando hotels, ~3,763 reviews), and the guest-review themes (small rooms, clean/renovated accommodations, budget value, friendly service)
Mickey Visit (May 2026), verified for the analysis identifying All-Star Sports as the lowest-rated Disney-owned resort in guest rankings, the least-immersive-theming and youth-sports-group noise/bus-congestion complaints, and the ESPN Wide World of Sports connection
Disney Fanatic and Disney Tourist Blog (2024-2026), verified for the cross-platform context (Yelp pointing to Coronado Springs, value-weighted rankings landing differently), demonstrating that the “worst” designation varies by methodology